Holy Flash-crash Batman.......what happened? The last hour yesterday, as demonstrated by the hourly SPY chart, show an implosion in price (it declined) and an explosion in volume (it blew up). There are as many explanations are there were trades that last hour. Gold was down 50, Silver down another 2.5, Oil was down 9.5, the whole commodity complex was down hard, the Euro was down 350 basis points, the Dollar was up135 basis points...almost 1.5% and the bond market was strong, with both the 10 year Note and the long Bond breaking through down trend resistance with authority. In other words, it was Risk Trade Off, Inflation Expectation dead, and Deflation straight ahead.
Of course, this morning, all of that is reversed, with the Dow, SPX and all other major indexes up over 1%, Commodity prices trending higher, the Dollar is flat and the Euro is bouncing, and the bond market gives back a little of yesterdays gains. I don't know how to spell schizophrenic, but if I did, it would be a great word to describe the markets..
The world of Momentum Changes has gotten a little confused, with the violent changes making it difficult to make sense of the indicators, which can't keep up with the price changes occurring in such a short period of time. That does not mean that they don't work, only that in a periods like the last 2 weeks with such violent changes in direction, it can become very confusing. It takes longer for the momentum measure to catch up with price changes, and by the time they catch up, the direction has again changed.
All of the last paragraph means only that it is imperative that stop loss orders be employed, both to prevent actual capital losses and to direct the harvesting of gains as they occur. No method of measuring the market is 100% accurate, 100% of the time. But we can keep on with the experience, realizing that even with the very quick loss yesterday that the traders of the past 2 weeks are still net very profitable.
Rob wrote yesterday, asking what "momentum change" had occurred to trigger the trades on Wednesday. The answer is that there was no Momentum Change... the last change was the Buy signal generated on 4/20. I reported the change 4/20 but I did not make any trade recommendations. I have trained myself to be very conservative, trying to trade only when the signals make sense in context with other measure of the market, and frankly, I did not like the market at that time. I wrote that if the resistance line and the IHS neck was broken to the up side, that there would be an opportunity to get into the market after a pull back.
Many technical manuals demonstrate that a stock or a market will often re-test a break out.. it is called "returning to Ice". Meaning that the stock or market will return to the break out point, and then resume that break-out direction with a successful test. It looked Wednesday that in fact the test occurred, and the shorter term charts showed a successful test, and I made the buy recommendations in the afternoon. Every trade closed Wed with a profit, and until about Mid-night when I closed the computer, the futures were trading up 30 points. I went to bed very satisfied.
By morning, the futures had pulled back to flat, and then the New Jobless claims printed with a big surprise on the up side, and with the higher margins in the Silver market, and other weakness in commodities, a comment from the ECB that a rate increase was unlikely in June, the whole investor-world tried to get out at the same time, and my stops were triggered on the open. Except for the QLD. Now this morning, it looks like Mr market wants to go higher again, the the Dow up 170 as this is written. Unfortunately, I don't have a technical rule about how to trade with this kind of action, so I will again wait until a new set-up presents its self on the upside, or I will watch for a new Sell signal. (which did not occur yesterday... but it was close)
I will mention that one of the old technical rules about trading the market is that violent swings after a big move higher often signify a topping process, and that historical observation is the context in which I am measuring this market.
Best To Your Trading!
Bill